Several recent articles have highlighted the growing interest among “Gen Z” youth and young adults in CTE-related careers. Generation Z is generally used to refer to individuals born roughly between 1997 and 2012 (with some debate on specifics), so currently covers individuals from middle school through young adulthood – many of whom are choosing to enroll in CTE programs.
The coverage of the changing interests of this generation emphasizes that there are significant labor shortages in skilled trades, including fields such as manufacturing, welding and construction. While many have debated how to fill these gaps and solve this issue, Generation Z has been showing an increased interest and participation in skilled trades programs and migrating away from four-year pathways.
Data is starting to support this trend as well. Enrollment in community colleges with a high CTE-program focus increased 16% from 2022 to 2023, as noted by the National Student Clearinghouse. In addition to this, 54% of Gen Z surveyed by New America have stated they believe a high school diploma is enough to secure a sustainable and lasting job upon completion. While in most cases, some postsecondary education is actually needed for careers with family-sustaining wages, this exemplifies the perception of today’s students. This shift is not only evident in how Gen Z pursues education, but even in the labor market in fields such as carpentry and HVAC maintenance, where Axios suggests that the median age of workers is younger than it has been in past decades.
The rising costs of postsecondary education, impact of the pandemic, rising student loan debt and high wages for many skilled trade workers are all mentioned as potential contributors to this shift.
In a podcast recorded for the Wall Street Journal, reporter Te-Ping Chen noted that some of the primary reasons that younger people might be gravitating toward skilled trades are compensation and security. Wages in the skilled trades are increasing; the median pay for new hires in the construction industry is around $48,000 compared to $39,000 for new hires in professional services.
Additionally, student loan debt has been a nationwide conversation of late, given the efforts of the Biden Administration to pass legislation to offer borrowers forgiveness of up to $20,000. This was followed by a new proposed forgiveness plan after the Supreme Court rejected the original proposal. The new student loan forgiveness plan would only apply to borrowers who entered repayment 20-25 years ago, but the conversation has elevated discourse in this area and gotten the attention of Gen Z learners. CTE programs and career training pathways such as apprenticeships often leave students with substantially less student debt, making it financially attractive for youth just beginning their careers.
Chen, alongside NPR contributor Windsor Johnston, also pointed out that there is much less concern with skilled trades professions being compromised by evolving technology such as AI. Rather, new technologies are introduced in these fields to increase appeal toward younger generations.
Gen Z is gravitating toward the skilled trades at a rate that will significantly impact the future of these industries as the demographics of workers shift, and as the nature and public perception of these jobs evolve as well. The perception shift also has the potential to significantly impact CTE program enrollment and demand, and policymakers will need to ensure the education and workforce systems have the capacity to meet the needs of all students.
Comments